Twenty-four cards with sixteen carol titles on each, no two the same. Play or sing a carol, call its title, and everyone holding that square marks it off. Thirty traditional carols in the pool, and a caller sheet at the back with every one of them and a tick box.
The squares are carol titles
Silent Night, Deck the Halls, In the Bleak Midwinter, Good King Wenceslas, Once in Royal David's City, Ding Dong Merrily on High, The Sussex Carol, I Saw Three Ships. Thirty in the pool, sixteen on each card, and the draw is different on every one.

Play eight bars, or sing the first line, or hand the job to whoever is at the piano. Ten to fifteen seconds of a familiar carol is enough, and it works the same with a choir or a phone through a speaker. Reading the titles out instead turns it into a plain word bingo for a room that would rather not guess.
The format
Four by four with no free square means sixteen titles per card and a line of four to win, which takes about ten to fifteen calls. That is a fifteen minute game, which is the right length before people want a different activity.
Each card is its own page and the caller sheet is the last one, listing all thirty carols with a tick box each so you can mark off what you have played. Twenty-four cards plus that sheet comes to twenty-five pages.
Move the grid to 5 by 5 if you want the game to run longer. That is twenty-four titles and a free centre square, so nearly the whole pool is on every card and the win comes from a line of five.
Variations worth trying
Hum or whistle instead of playing, which is harder and funnier. Or start in the middle of a verse rather than at the opening, which rewards the people who know the carol over the people who recognise an intro.
Questions
- What is actually printed on the cards?
- Sixteen carol titles per card, drawn from a pool of thirty: Silent Night, Away in a Manger, The First Noel, Deck the Halls, O Holy Night, The Sussex Carol and the rest. Titles only, no lyrics and no music.
- Can I play this at a public event?
- The sheets themselves are fine anywhere, because every carol named is traditional and long out of copyright. Playing a particular recording in public depends on your own music licence, which is why live or sung versions are the simpler option.
- How long does a game last?
- Ten to fifteen calls for a line of four, which is roughly fifteen minutes including the time people take to find each title on their card.
- How many cards can I print?
- This page starts at twenty-four, and the control goes up to thirty. Each card is its own page, so twenty-four cards plus the caller sheet is a twenty-five page PDF.