Headed paper from the desk of Father Christmas, with the letter already written and four gaps to fill: the child's name after Dear, two things they have their eye on in the middle of it, and one line under A Special Mention This Year For. It closes with a word about leaving a carrot by the door and a signature from the North Pole.
The one line that does the work
The special mention line is where you put something true: the school play they were in, the tooth that came out, that they have started getting themselves dressed, the dog they walk. Children accept a great deal when the letter knows one thing nobody outside the house would know.
Keep it to one thing. The rest of the letter already covers the post sack, the elves, the big book and the carrot, and a second specific makes the whole thing read like somebody trying.
What the letter promises, and does not
It says the name is written in the big book, and that the only jobs left are hanging a stocking on Christmas Eve, making sure the fire is out and getting to sleep early. The two wish fields sit in a line that says I see you have your eye on, so what the child asked for is acknowledged rather than promised. Nothing on the sheet confirms a gift, which is deliberate.

Confirming a present that then does not arrive is the one way a letter from Santa causes real trouble. If you add a line by hand, keep it to being glad they wrote rather than to what is coming.
Printing it
Type the four fields and print, or print it blank and write them in by hand. If you write them, use a pen you do not normally use: children compare handwriting more carefully than adults expect.
Use 100gsm or heavier if your printer takes it. Thin copier paper is the detail children notice, more than the wording is.
Questions
- What does the letter from Santa say?
- That the letter arrived safely in the big red post sack, that the elves have reported well of the child, that their name is in the big book, and to leave a carrot by the door. Four blanks are left for you to fill in.
- Does the letter promise a present?
- No, and that is deliberate. Confirming a gift that then does not arrive is the one way this goes wrong, so the letter is warm about the child without committing to anything.
- What do I put in the special mention line?
- One true thing: a school play, a lost tooth, a pet they look after, something they have learned to do alone. One specific is more convincing than three general compliments.
- Is the signature printed?
- Yes. Father Christmas is set in italics above a signature rule, with The North Pole underneath. Sign over it in your own hand if you would rather.