Notice From The North Pole across the top, then Naughty List, and underneath it in italics: provisional, and still under review. The name goes on a wide rule, with a line saying the list is read again on the 24th, a What Would Do It section, a seal, and Reviewed By and Date at the foot.
Who this is for
Adults and older children who are in on the joke. A colleague who keeps taking the good mugs, a brother who ate the chocolates, a flatmate who has still not put the recycling out. Printed on card and slipped into a Secret Santa gift, it lands well.
It is not for a young child who believes in the list. A four year old handed an official notice saying they are on the naughty list does not read it as a joke, and the result is tears rather than a laugh. The nice list certificate exists for that age group.
Why it says provisional
The whole sheet is written as a review rather than a verdict: still under review at the top, there is still time in the middle, and the list is read again on the 24th. Even as a joke, that is what keeps it affectionate instead of mean.
The What Would Do It line is where you say how to get off it. For an older child who is in on the joke, write something achievable and specific there and then honour it, and the notice becomes a game rather than a judgement.

The foot of the sheet
Reviewed By rather than signed, which is the small detail that makes the whole thing read as bureaucracy rather than as Santa being cross with somebody. Put a name in it, or leave it and let them wonder.
One notice fills a sheet. Print on 160gsm card if it is going inside a gift, because a notice on copier paper reads as a note rather than as a document, and the joke depends on it looking official.
Questions
- Is a naughty list notice suitable for a young child?
- No. A child who believes in the list reads an official notice as a verdict rather than a joke. Use the nice list certificate for younger children and keep this one for adults and older children who are in on it.
- Can somebody get off the naughty list?
- That is the point of the sheet. It says the decision is provisional and the list is read again on the 24th, with a What Would Do It line for you to fill in.
- Can I use this for an office Secret Santa?
- Yes, that is one of the better uses. Printed on card and tucked into a gift it works well, as long as the recipient has the sort of humour that enjoys it.
- What can I type into it?
- The name, the What Would Do It line, the Reviewed By line and the date. Everything else is fixed wording, which is what makes it look like a document rather than a note.